Kit vs Mailchimp vs Buttondown: What a Newsletter Actually Costs in 2026
If you write a technical or creator newsletter in 2026, the three names you will keep meeting are Kit (formerly ConvertKit), Mailchimp and Buttondown. They look similar from the landing page and completely different on the invoice: at 5,000 subscribers, a realistic monthly bill ranges from $29 (Buttondown) to $100 (Mailchimp Standard) — and Kit's free plan quietly covers lists ten times larger than Mailchimp's paid entry tier.
At a glance
| Kit | Mailchimp | Buttondown | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free plan ceiling | 10,000 subscribers | 250 contacts, 500 sends/mo | 100 subscribers |
| Entry paid plan | Creator, $39/mo | Essentials, $13/mo | $9/mo |
| Billing unit | Subscribers (no send limits) | Contacts stored — including unsubscribed | Active subscribers only |
| Paid subscriptions for readers | Yes (Pro tier for the full referral system) | Not the focus | Yes, 0% platform cut (Stripe fees apply) |
| Watch out for | 2025 price rise: Creator went $29 → $39 | Free plan cut 3 times since 2023; overages | Features sold as per-item add-ons |
Pricing at real list sizes
Monthly billing, cheapest plan that fits, US dollars. Kit figures are the monthly-billing rate; paying yearly brings Creator to $33/mo and Pro to $66/mo at 1,000 subscribers.
| List size | Kit Creator | Kit Pro | Mailchimp Essentials | Mailchimp Standard | Buttondown |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 | $39 | $79 | $26.50 | $45 | $9 |
| 5,000 | $89 | — | $75 | $100 | $29 |
| 10,000 | $139 | — | $110 | $135 | $79 |
| Free until | 10,000 subscribers | 250 contacts | 100 subscribers | ||
Two things stand out. First, Kit's free plan is the outlier of the whole category: unlimited sends to up to 10,000 subscribers at $0, with landing pages and basic tagging included. The catch is that automations and sequences effectively stop on the free tier — the moment you want a welcome sequence, you are on Creator at $39/mo. Second, Mailchimp's ladder climbs fastest: Standard at 10,000 contacts is $135/mo, and that is before overages.
Where the bill hides
Mailchimp bills you for people who left
Mailchimp counts subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts toward your tier. Only archived or deleted contacts stop costing money. A neglected list with 30% dead weight pays for all of it. Mailchimp also cut its free plan again in early 2026 — from 500 contacts and 1,000 sends to 250 contacts and 500 sends a month — the third cut since 2023, so treat the free tier as a trial, not a home.
Kit's 2025 price rise
In September 2025 Kit raised prices for the first time in 12 years: Creator went from $29 to $39 a month at 1,000 subscribers, and Pro from $59 to $79. Older reviews quoting $15 or $29 Creator pricing are stale. Selling digital products through Kit also carries a 3.5% + $0.30 transaction fee on every plan.
Buttondown's add-on menu
Buttondown's $9 base is genuinely cheap, and it only counts active subscribers. But features other tools bundle are line items: tagging and segmentation, analytics, RSS-to-email and paid subscriptions are $9/mo each, and automations are $29/mo. A writer who wants paid subscriptions plus analytics plus tagging pays $9 + $27 = $36/mo at 1,000 subscribers — still competitive, but no longer $9. The upside: Buttondown takes 0% of paid-subscription revenue, where creator platforms commonly take a cut on top of Stripe's fees.
Which one should you pick?
- Pick Kit if your newsletter is a business in the making: you will sell a course, a template pack or a paid tier, and you want funnels, tagging and commerce in one place. Grow free to 10,000 subscribers first; budget $39/mo from the day you need automations.
- Pick Buttondown if you are a developer or writer who wants Markdown, a custom sending domain, an API and a hosted archive — without a marketing suite attached. It is the cheapest honest way to run a paid newsletter at small scale.
- Pick Mailchimp if you run an online store and need its e-commerce automations, audience tooling and integrations, and you have the discipline to archive dead contacts every month.
Links above are affiliate links (see disclosure). Pricing confirmed on the vendors' sites as of November 2026.